Cheering Against the Tide: Why Egypt’s National Team Has Lost Some of Its Fans

What happened was not a revolt against football, but against what it represents when it is emptied of its meaning. The fans are no longer looking for victory on the pitch, but for sincerity in faces. And when this sincerity was absent, the stands went dark of their own accord, because enthusiasm cannot be imposed by a call or by a fatwa.

Mahmoud Saeed

If you are a true lover of Egyptian cinema, that scene may still be stuck in your memory: Mohamed Sharaf in Zarf Tarek, sitting next to Ahmed Helmy and Magdy Kamel, watching a match of the Egyptian national team. The moment a goal went into our net was enough to ignite anger on their faces, but Sharaf, contrary to what is usual, smiled, cheered and applauded the opposing team. Those sitting with him were confused, and the audience laughed, but behind that comedy lay a deeper idea about belonging, disappointment, and joy when a person does not find himself in what is supposed to “represent” him.

Remember the whole scene… perhaps you will find in it features of what we are living today.

 

Well, it seems that the scene did not remain confined to the cinema screen; it stepped out of it and walked on two feet among us.

What was fiction in a film has become a reality looking out at us from phone screens. A strange phenomenon has begun to spread across social media: Egyptian fans turning their backs on their national team, and declaring without equivocation that it no longer represents them.

The explanations are many, but one question presses on minds: what has changed? And what has broken between people and what they once saw as a symbol of their unity?

A chant against the tide

The answer is no riddle. The shift in how we view football is nothing but a reflection of a deeper shift that touched our entire consciousness after 7 October. That day, Palestine returned to the centre of the picture, not as a passing news item, but as an open wound in the conscience of the world.

Since that day, the world has been witnessing massacre after massacre: the bombing of the Baptist Hospital, the Jabalia camp massacre, the extermination of entire families in Gaza and Tulkarm, and the targeting of UNRWA schools, doctors, journalists, and even those who lift the rubble with their bare hands. Graves are dug up, bodies are executed in the field, and a people is starved in front of the cameras.

In contrast, the steadfastness of the resistance is revealed, and the old language of anti-colonialism returns to the forefront, regarding the occupation not as an aberration from history, but as an extension of it. The tone in the world is changing, and the Palestinian narrative is prevailing over the Zionist propaganda machine, even if step by step.

Thus Palestine became, once again, the compass that restores meaning to us, and reminds us of what had long been absent from our minds: that the causes of peoples do not die, but they fall silent when we are preoccupied with life’s trivialities at the expense of its essence.

Did you not feel that Wael Al-Dahdouh, when he stood before the camera after losing his entire family, was bigger than his profession, and deeper than his grief?
That steadfastness, which did not waver despite everything, was not a passing scene in news bulletins, but a lesson in human meaning itself. Our tears did not fall merely out of emotion, but because they awakened in us something we had almost lost: that Palestine is not a political event, but a touchstone for the conscience of the world, and for our own consciousness too.
Perhaps that emotional return is what made millions boycott the products supporting the Zionist entity without any call or theorising; as if they were discovering for the first time their capacity to act.

This renewed awareness does not appear as a passing emotion, but as a precise naming of what the Moroccan researcher Fathallah Oualalou described in his study published by the Policy Center for the New South under the title A History of Grievance. He was not talking about a single event, but about an extended system.
From the Nakba in 1948, which turned an entire people into refugees, to a legal system that tightens control over land and resources, then to the 1967 occupation and the settlements and walls that followed it, all the way to the siege of Gaza, which turned daily life into collective punishment.
And in the background of all this, a media machine that shapes the narrative as it pleases with three recurring tricks: stripping away context so that violence appears as if it were born out of a vacuum, a false equivalence between two parties that are not equal, and the use of the passive voice to hide the perpetrator.
Thus, the description “a history of grievance” becomes not a lament, but an anatomy of a power structure that produces injustice day after day, and that makes the act of resistance, and solidarity itself, a moral necessity, not a political choice.

 

 

الدورات الرمضانيّة: من فنّ الشارع والكرة إلى فنّ التسييس

The “Salah” attack

With this deep transformation in the collective consciousness, it was natural for its wave to extend to everything that was once a symbol of identity and belonging, even football. The fans no longer look at the national team as they used to, nor at its players as heroes raising the banner, but as mirrors reflecting the growing distance between the people and those who are supposed to represent them. From here one can understand the tremor that struck the relationship between the fans and Mohamed Salah in particular, that symbol who went beyond the limits of the pitch to become an “Egyptian model” for the world, before suddenly turning into a mirror that shows what we do not like to see in ourselves: distance, silence, and disavowal of the great causes. But before we put Salah on trial or acquit him, we must remember how things were only a few years ago, when doubting the national team was an emotional crime.

Remember the Zarf Tarek scene again: how Ahmed Helmy and Magdy Kamel treated their colleague who cheered for the opposing team as if he had committed national treason. The comedy may have exaggerated, but it touched the truth precisely. In the conscience of Egyptians at that time, whoever did not chant for the national team did not chant for Egypt. Belonging was as much about football as it was national, and the chants in the stands were part of the very idea of the homeland.

Now, however, the picture is different. If you stood in the middle of Cairo at the peak of the crowds and announced that you boycott the national team’s matches and do not see it as representing you, accusations would not rain down on you as used to happen in the past. You will find someone nodding his head like one who has found a ready-made sentence for what is churning in his chest, someone who holds back out of an old nostalgia, and someone who humours you with words and then retreats for fear of breaking an inherited habit. What has changed, then? It is not only the sporting mood that has shifted, but the very meaning of representation. The fans no longer grant the badge of belonging for free, and have begun to measure symbols by a moral standard, not by the standard of colours and anthems. The stadium is no longer a space for spectating, but a small test of the idea of citizenship. And when the symbols fail this test, the silence in the stands speaks louder than all the chants.

Believe it or not, this transformation did not leave its mark only on public debate; it reached the concrete seats themselves. The national team’s manager, Mohamed Khaled Ghoraba, complains after the Djibouti match about the absence of the fans, and the technical director, Rui Vitória, looks around Cairo Stadium and sees only a few thousand people scattered in a sea of empty seats. Hazem Emam, who knew the roar of a hundred thousand, describes the scene in a tone of disappointment: national teams play better when their fans support them. The scene seems simple on the surface, but it reveals something deeper than what is said in statements. The stands, which were a mirror of national emotion, have become a measure of trust. And when trust is shaken, neither results nor promotional shots can make up for it.

Then comes Mohamed Salah’s statement on ON Time Sports wishing for the fans’ return, followed by a fatwa from Dar al-Ifta describing support for the national team as a national duty. Here the paradox appears in its clearest form. When cheering turns into a duty, we lose its essence as a free act and a meaning that gains its legitimacy from solidarity, not from obligation. And when religious language is summoned to back a football match, the fans feel that the message is turned upside down. What is required is not to impose attendance, but to restore the meaning that makes attendance a necessity of its own accord. And because this meaning was absent, the attack on the fans emerged, portraying them as offering support only when winning. The truth is simpler and harsher: people give support when they see themselves in those who ask for it. If this reflection is absent, they withdraw without noise.

This is not about Mohamed Salah alone. The issue is broader than a player, a statement or the absence of a stance. What is happening is a disintegration of the relationship between “representation” and “identification”. The fans no longer see in the national team’s players an extension of themselves, but a separate class, living in another reality, and speaking a language that does not resemble theirs.
When Salah, Mido or Hazem Emam call on the fans for support, people hear a paternalistic tone in their words, as if those at the top were asking those at the bottom to applaud so that the game can go on. But the game, in people’s new consciousness, is no longer just ninety minutes on the pitch, but a complete mirror of the country, of justice, and of the voice that is heard and suppressed.

Salah, without realising it, contributed to entrenching this gap. His astonishing success abroad was met by an astonishing silence at home, as if he had decided that neutrality is the safest form of intelligence. But he forgot that Egyptian fans do not celebrate success alone, but what success represents in terms of solidarity, dignity and stance. And when they saw their stars taking refuge in silence at a time that needs a voice, they felt that they were alone in the battle.
An emotional gap formed that cannot be bridged, not because people hate Salah, but because they no longer see themselves in him. He was once “one of us”, then became “one of them”; and this psychological distance is what made the stands cold even when the national team wins.

And because football in Egypt has always been an extension of politics, this gap turned into an even clearer mirror. The fans who used to applaud passionately in Cairo Stadium are the same ones who chant in the streets for the great causes, and who know well that belonging is not reduced to raising the flag, but lies in raising one’s voice.
So it was not strange that the “Stadium of Terror” was emptied of its soul. It is not laziness or indifference, but a redefinition of what deserves enthusiasm in the first place.

A seventeen-year-old chant

“In sympathy with Gaza”.. two words that Abou Treika wrote on his shirt seventeen years ago, and they still ring in the memory of an entire nation. The match was ordinary on the surface, Egypt against Sudan at the 2008 Africa Cup of Nations, but the moment was not. While the sky over Gaza was ablaze with bombardment, a player decided to break his silence and raise a shirt bearing what many had been unable to say.

Abou Treika later recounts, in a documentary for beIN Sports, how he thought all night about what he could do, how he himself made two shirts bearing the phrase, and how he hid them in the room so that no one would know. He was not in the starting line-up for the match, but fate brought the ball to him, so he scored, and raised the shirt before the cameras, so that the picture that would outlive the goal itself was captured.

That moment went beyond mere symbolic sympathy; it was a declaration that a player can be an active citizen, and that the body running on the pitch can turn, when it wishes, into a voice in the face of injustice.
In that luminous shot, people understood that heroism is not measured by the number of goals, but by the extent of a person’s connection to what transcends himself.

What Abou Treika did was not so much an individual act of heroism as a breaking of the chain of fear.
He knew that his act might cost him a great deal, and perhaps end his career, but he chose to do “what must be done”, not “what is permitted”.
This stripped-down simplicity of the act is what made his moment immortal; because it reminded everyone that freedom does not need permission, and that a word, when it comes from the heart, can shake an entire regime.

But the most beautiful part of the story was not raising the shirt, but what happened after it.
When Abou Treika expected a reprimand from the technical staff, Hassan Shehata surprised him with a different response: he did not reprimand him for doing it, but for doing it alone, without telling them so that they could make thirty-five more shirts for the whole team to wear.
That was the moment when the barrier dissolved between the “national team” and the “homeland”, between the coach and the fans, between what is said in politics and what is done in sport. The spirit was one, the tone was one, and the sentiment was shared.

From there, the national team became known as the “team of those who prostrate”, not only because they knelt in thanks after goals, but because they also bowed before a deeper idea: that victory without principle is a postponed defeat.

Today, however, the scene is radically different. The stands that used to resemble an open popular celebration have turned into silent seats filled with strangers who do not know what it means to chant from your heart. Football is no longer a unifying event, but a closed class activity. Ticket prices rose, and security restrictions multiplied, so the real audience that used to see in a match an escape from life’s worries disappeared, and was replaced by a limited audience that watches with boredom and applauds without belonging.

In the past, the stands were a miniature image of Egypt itself: a mixture of classes, dialects and faces that united in the moment of a goal. Cheering was an emotional act that encapsulated a feeling of belonging. Today, belonging is no longer measured by chanting, but by the ability to buy a ticket. Thus the game turned from a symbol of the people into a privilege for those who can pay the price of a seat.

With this change in the shape of the audience, the features of the players also changed. For many of them, football became a means of individual advancement that has nothing to do with any collective meaning. The collective consciousness embodied by the Abou Treika generation disappeared, and a generation emerged that sees in its nation’s causes only a burden that can be evaded with a diplomatic statement or a silent smile. The player became a “brand” more than a symbol, and everything is calculated: the tweet, the photo, and even the moral stance.

And because the standards have been turned upside down, some players have come to court the symbolic authority of their stars more than they court their fans. The scene in which Mostafa Mohamed raised Salah’s shirt in the face of the fans after scoring a goal is not merely a moment of enthusiasm; it is a symbolic declaration of a new alliance within the game: loyalty upwards, not downwards, to the party that grants legitimacy, not to the party that creates it. Hence, it was natural for the fans to lose their passion, because they no longer see themselves in those who wear the shirt in their name.

Thus, the problem is no longer people’s reluctance to cheer, but what made them turn away in the first place. When the game is emptied of its social meaning, and the relationship of the heart is replaced by a market relationship, the silence in the stands becomes more eloquent than any chant.

Scenes We Did Not See from Ahmed Refaat’s Funeral

This is what is happening in “Cairo”

The most important reason, as many see it, is that what has changed is not only in football, but in our view of the entire world. 7 October was not a passing political event, but a moment of rupture and realisation that restored to people their awareness of the essence. With the return of the Palestinian cause to the forefront, priorities were rearranged in minds and hearts alike, and many things fell from their old standing, even football itself.

What was previously considered a symbol of patriotism came to be measured by a new standard. Patriotism no longer lies in raising your country’s flag at a match, but in raising your voice with the oppressed, and in your belonging being an extension of your humanity, not of a slogan on a shirt. This is why Mohamed Salah, despite his footballing glory, is no longer a symbol on which Egyptians agree, because they are no longer looking for the brilliant player, but for the human being who speaks honestly when everyone falls silent.

In contrast, other peoples, such as South Africa, gained deep respect among Arab fans, because they stood by the Palestinian cause with courage and steadfastness. In the minds of many, supporting its national team became closer to an act of moral solidarity than to a sporting competition. The definition of “the team we love” changed because the definition of “the right we believe in” also changed.

A new reading of reality was born from the womb of the war. Young people who were prisoners of screens, not reading a single page of a book, began to study history and politics in depth, analysing the articles of Ilan Pappé, Rashid Khalidi, Gideon Levy and Abdel Wahab El-Messiri. “Generation Z”, which used to be accused of shallowness, turned into a generation more aware and more capable of linking meaning and stance, between what it sees on the screen and what it lives in its daily life.

Thus, the grand equation changed. The fans no longer applaud merely for goals, but for whoever carries a cause, and patriotism is no longer a slogan raised in stadiums, but a behaviour that links Cairo and Gaza, cheering and stance. In light of this understanding, siding with whoever stands with Palestine, whatever their nationality, has become more patriotic than chanting for those who ignore it. As the Sudanese fan Adam Omar said: “Whoever supports Palestine loves his land whatever its name, and whoever does not feel for it, his love for his homeland is incomplete”.

What is happening in Cairo is not an exception, but an image of a wide global scene. The awareness that emerged after “Al-Aqsa Flood” has crossed borders, and has begun to redefine the concepts themselves: from justice, to belonging, to the meaning of being human in a time when everything is measured by neutrality. No one is waiting for guidance from above any more, because people have realised that a single individual, when acting sincerely, can make a real impact.

Thus, when a woman goes out alone in the middle of Cairo, chanting for Palestine amid the crowds, she is not doing so only in protest, but as a reclaiming of a greater meaning: that the free voice, however lonely it may seem, is worth an entire nation that finally knows who represents it, and what it is chanting for.

What happened was not a revolt against football, but against what it represents when it is emptied of its meaning. The fans are no longer looking for victory on the pitch, but for sincerity in faces. And when this sincerity was absent, the stands went dark of their own accord, because enthusiasm cannot be imposed by a call or by a fatwa.
What we see today is not a reluctance to cheer, but a silent resistance against falseness, a soft protest from a nation that still knows well when to chant, and for whom.

Thus football intersects with political awareness, and patriotism meets human dignity at a single point: that representation is not granted, but earned. And that whoever wants people to applaud him must first resemble them, and truly belong to them, not look down on them from afar.

Perhaps the scene of Mohamed Sharaf in Zarf Tarek was a prophecy that we did not understand at the time. He was not cheering a goal in our net, but laughing at a reality he did not see as his own. And today, after many long years, it seems that all of us, in some way, have sat in the same scene, laughing bitterly at a team that no longer plays in our name, and waiting for a moment in which we restore meaning to joy.

 

لماذا لا يثور المصريون؟ عن المسيرة العالمية إلى غزة، وصناعة اللا جدوى

Editorial correction: The first version of the article stated that Abou Treika wrote the phrase “In sympathy with Gaza” on his shirt fifteen years ago; in fact, it was seventeen years ago, as he raised the shirt in the match between Egypt and Sudan at the 2008 Africa Cup of Nations.

Add Zawia3 to your preferred sources on Google

Search